Interesting timing – shortly after posting yesterday’s thoughts on strange bridge claiming habits, I wandered over to the BridgeWinners forum. I’m only playing in two days of the Tarrytown Regional, but one is with a first-time partner and I love the online convention card editor they have!
Bad Claim Story
Right in the top of my news feed, a posting about a top level bridge player making an erroneous claim, with possibly a bad ruling by the director. Again, we are only hearing one side of the story, but apparently the declarer in a slam claimed on trick 3, representing that he started with 7 spades (trump), 2 hearts, 3 diamonds, and a stiff club (KQx clubs in dummy to pitch a heart loser). Don’t feel too bad for the protagonist though, shortly after he found out he was the lucky $100 winner of the GNYBA frequent player drawing.
What Happens In A Bad Claim?
I’ve heard too many horror stories on what happens during a bad claim. Even when the players call the directors immediately, it’s stressful for everyone. The player making the claim should have provided the line of play (prior to director call). When crucial details are not provided, things get interesting. Clearly the defenders can’t argue you will play stupidly and clash your aces on your kings, or ruff your winners. But if there is a guess involved (two reasonable ways to finesse), then you won’t be given the benefit of the doubt.
Too Trusting?
At least in the mid-flight levels, I’ve found most defenders are too quick to show their hands during a claim, prior to hearing the line of play. Sometimes players say “play it out”, which is also technically not proper (it gives back rights that I surrendered after claiming).
Even if 95% of the time the claim is rock solid, should we be a little more careful?